State of Texas vs. Sony (cd trojan lawsuit)
by Vashner · in General Discussion · 11/21/2005 (3:33 pm) · 25 replies
www.woai.com/news/local/story.aspx?content_id=74963E48-FF37-47E4-98B1-560D400056...
Quote:Texas Sues Sony Over "Spyware" CDs
LAST UPDATE: 11/21/2005 5:24:21 PM
Posted By: Jim Forsyth
This story is available on your cell phone at mobile.woai.com.
The state of Texas today sued the giant record company Sony BMG, claiming the company's attachment of so called 'spyware filed' to CD's of more than fifty artists amounts to a violation of the new Consumer Protection Against Computer Spyware Act, which was approved by the legislature earlier this year, 1200 WOAI news reported today.
The lawsuit, filed by Attorney General Greg Abbott, seeks $100,000 for each violation, and considering that millions of CD's were shipped, means damages could soar into the hundreds of billions of dollars.
"Sony has engaged in a technological version of cloak and dagger deceit against consumers by hiding secret files on their computers," Abbott said.
Sony BMG, which is one of the world's largest music distributors, admitted last week that it placed embedded files designed to prevent the discs from being copied on millions of discs of 52 artists. But Abbott says when consumers try to play the CD's on their computers, they are required to click 'yes' on an agreement that they will not copy the discs, and that click installs 'secret files' on the computer hard drive which opens the computer to viruses.
Sony claims that it has recalled all of the discs, but Abbott says his investigators were able to purchase 'numerous titles' at an Austin record store Sunday night.
The lawsuit also alleges that a 'phantom file' is included on the disc which prevents the consumer from seeing the hidden files, making it difficult or impossible for the files to be removed.
Computer web sites have charged that the files also make a user more vulnerable to identity theft, something Sony BMG denies.
"Consumers who purchased a Sony CD thought they were buying music," Abbott said. "Instead, they received spyware that can damage a computer and subject it to viruses."
#22
11/22/2005 (10:30 am)
Its bullshit that the only people that are the target of the malicious code are only the paying customers. The protection still doesnt circumvent ripping the cds by third party programs (EAC). Its useless malware. Sony deserves this suit. Even if they lose under the current circumstance the ridiculous money amount will be appealed and settled on for much less- just like all these tobacco lawsuits that happen all the time here. but it should still send a message and i hope other states follow if they don't drop the protection.
#23
11/22/2005 (10:57 am)
Well, then you also have the private server phenomenon among online titles like Ragnarok or zone duplicators that capture online data streams for offline exploitation. I'm not sure how to solve the problem or even block the problem. Since I abhor MMO games (not because of PK'ing, hacking, etc that most people complain about, but because they haven't yet been worth even a casual week's worth of gameplay, let alone months and months). It is a captivating martket, but we have to get past our entrenched views on software security and distribution to figure out how to combat abuse.
#24
But man, does Sony deserve this after pulling this kinda crap.
Piracy sucks. I've very much against it. But this crap - holding your customers at gunpoint, violating the integrity of their $2500 machine so they can protect their $16 CD... that's completely reprehensible.
11/22/2005 (2:32 pm)
I fear for this opening up a whole bunch of lawsuits for far less deserving companies (does your indie game automatically check for an online high-score list? Does that mean YOU will get sued for millions?).But man, does Sony deserve this after pulling this kinda crap.
Piracy sucks. I've very much against it. But this crap - holding your customers at gunpoint, violating the integrity of their $2500 machine so they can protect their $16 CD... that's completely reprehensible.
#25
I want a refund. It's like if you buy a car and every night they jump the fence..
Wait your tires are too good.. here are 4 spare rim riders. Then wait.. your engine. .that's too big.
If your new car was made my Sony online by the time they finished it would go from a Mustang GT
to a Vespa scooter in Mexico with 3 people on it.
11/22/2005 (2:56 pm)
Next they need to sue them for nerfing swords and armor in EQ / EQ2 :)I want a refund. It's like if you buy a car and every night they jump the fence..
Wait your tires are too good.. here are 4 spare rim riders. Then wait.. your engine. .that's too big.
If your new car was made my Sony online by the time they finished it would go from a Mustang GT
to a Vespa scooter in Mexico with 3 people on it.
Associate Joseph Euan